Nellie has done well at left back in the last couple of friendlies but you always feel he is on the verge of doing something silly & getting sent off. Personally i would play Nelthorpe in a 3-5-2 formation as a wing back as he can cross well. If we play 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 i would play Meynell.
I think Meynell should get the job after all that's what he's been brought in for. As garage says he could have been sent off a few times he can't keep his mouth shut and he's quick to retaliate if he gets beaten to often.
Nelthorpe made a instant impact this afternoon when he came on, a thunderbolt shot on target, and a clearance at the other end, with Killock. And, he actually played more minutes and full 90 minute games ahead of Meynell in pre season, collecting man of the match in one of the games.
Though Meynell had a great game today, as did Turner on the other flank. Worked their socks off and showed their experience and class for the whole 90 mins.